Governance
Summary
Blockchains are distributed systems. They are essentially consensus protocols, which means that different nodes in the network (e.g. computers on the internet) have to be running compatible software.
“Node operators” are the owners and managers of nodes that run the protocol. Most node operators don’t want to write much software, and it’s a technical challenge for anyone to independently write compatible implementations of any consensus protocol even if they have a specification. As a result, node operators rely on software repositories (usually hosted on Microsoft/Github servers) to provide them with the software they choose to run.
“Core developers” of a blockchain are software developers who work on the software that implement that protocol. Developers have processes that are supposed to assure the quality of the software they release, and are generally very interested in maintaining the legitimacy of their software repositories because they want to see people using their software (as opposed to someone else’s).
Critical Components of Governance
1. Incentives
Each group in the system has their own incentives. Those incentives are not always 100% aligned with all other groups in the system. Groups will propose changes over time which are advantageous for them. Organisms are biased towards their own survival. This commonly manifests in changes to the reward structure, monetary policy, or balances of power.
2. Mechanisms for Coordination
Since it’s unlikely all groups have 100% incentive alignment at all times, the ability for each group to coordinate around their common incentives is critical for them to affect change. If one group can coordinate better than another, it creates power imbalances in their favor.
In practice, a major factor is how much coordination can be done on-chain vs. off-chain, where on-chain coordination makes coordinating easier. In some new blockchains (such as Tezos or Polkadot), on-chain coordination allows the rules or even the ledger history itself to be changed.
On-Chain Governance
Current governance systems in Bitcoin and Ethereum are informal. They were designed using a decentralized ethos, first promulgated by Satoshi Nakamoto in his original paper. Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
What is on-chain governance?
On-chain governance is a system for managing and implementing changes to cryptocurrency blockchains. In this type of governance, rules for instituting changes are encoded into the blockchain protocol. Developers propose changes through code updates and each node votes on whether to accept or reject the proposed change.
How does it work?
Unlike informal governance systems, which use a combination of offline coordination and online code modifications to effect changes, on-chain governance systems solely work online. Changes to a blockchain are proposed through code updates. Subsequently, nodes can vote to accept or decline the change. Not all nodes have equal voting power. Nodes with greater holdings of coins have more votes as compared to nodes that have a relatively lesser number of holdings.
If the change is accepted, it is included in the blockchain and baselined. In some instances of on-chain governance implementation, the updated code may be rolled back to its version before a baseline, if the proposed change is unsuccessful.
Pros
It is a decentralized form of governance
Quicker turnaround times for changes
Possibility of a hard fork is reduced significantly
Cons
Low-voter turnout
Tends towards plutocracy (users with greater stakes can manipulate votes)
Off-Chain Governance
What is off-chain governance?
Off-chain governance looks and behaves a lot similarly to politics in the existing world. Various interest groups attempt to control the network through a series of coordination games in which they try to convince everyone else to support their side. There is no code that binds these groups to specific behaviors, but rather, they choose what’s in their best interest given the known preferences of the other stakeholders. There’s a reason blockchain technology and game theory are so interwoven.
How does it work?
Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
The various stakeholders signal their approval or disapproval for an improvement proposal through private and community discourse. Then, the core developers get a sense for whether or not node operators and miners will agree to upgrade their software. Ideally, all sides agree and the code changes are made smoothly. Everything is announced beforehand and stakeholders have time to update.
In the case of disagreement, stakeholders have two options. First, they can try and convince the other stakeholders to act in favor of their side. If they can’t reach consensus, they have the ability to hard fork the protocol and keep or change features they think are necessary. From there, both chains have to compete for brand, users, developer mindshare, and hash power.
GPU Miningneo bitcoin byzantium ethereum lite bitcoin usb tether bitcoin agario Cypherpunks were left without this piece of their puzzle until 2008, when a person (or group) operating under the pseudonym 'Satoshi Nakamoto' released a whitepaper detailing a viable solution to the problem. 'Bitcoin: A Peer to Peer Electronic Cash System' outlined a system which was fully peer to peer (i.e. it had no central point of failure). Traditionally, a central authority had been required to ensure that the unit of e-cash was not 'double-spent'.Say, for instance, that I wanted to pay you for each minute of video that I watched. We would open up a lightning channel, and as the minutes rolled by, periodic payments would be made from my wallet to yours. When I’m done watching, we would close the channel to settle the net amount on the bitcoin blockchain.терминалы bitcoin ethereum wikipedia
ssl bitcoin
bitcoin форумы bitcoin analysis
цена ethereum bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin вики
accept bitcoin monero proxy
1024 bitcoin график ethereum ethereum windows decred cryptocurrency компиляция bitcoin bitcoin main bitcoin лохотрон
bitcoin андроид monero алгоритм бесплатно ethereum ethereum форки bitcoin icon bitcoin 999 monero форум зарегистрироваться bitcoin se*****256k1 bitcoin In North America, the biggest mining operation, run by MegaBigPower located in Washington State by the Columbia River, in which a hydroelectric power is overflowing and the prices of electricity are the cheapest in the nation. CloudHasing as well, runs a big mining operation located in Iceland, in which electricity is generated from geothermal and hydroelectric power sources that is likewise cheap and renewable, and also gives cooling due to the cold northern climate.calculator bitcoin bitcoin аналоги bitcoin sportsbook forum ethereum алгоритм ethereum pool monero bitcoin motherboard
bitcoin satoshi java bitcoin bitcoin network bitcoin fan сложность bitcoin краны monero rise cryptocurrency bitcoin удвоитель bootstrap tether ava bitcoin bitcoin instagram
разделение ethereum all bitcoin p2pool monero bitcoin info bitcoin changer bitcoin habrahabr ethereum github monster bitcoin adc bitcoin bitcoin fork bitcoin stock bitcoin algorithm bitcoin euro значок bitcoin bitcoin clock bitcoin команды cryptocurrency price хабрахабр bitcoin tracker bitcoin ads bitcoin
ethereum logo se*****256k1 ethereum free ethereum wired tether
bitcoin упал bitcoin video проверка bitcoin курс bitcoin bitcoin js ethereum стоимость supernova ethereum ethereum рубль monero 1070 cryptocurrency mining партнерка bitcoin bitcoin nyse talk bitcoin casino bitcoin msigna bitcoin lootool bitcoin платформа bitcoin monero пул card bitcoin collector bitcoin avto bitcoin bitcoin ubuntu 2 bitcoin bitcoin nonce bitcoin блог bitcoin dance вклады bitcoin курс tether bitcoin trading bitcoin land bitcoin scam san bitcoin вывод bitcoin bitcoin серфинг bitcoin donate email bitcoin добыча ethereum bitcoin keywords hashrate bitcoin bitcoin department preev bitcoin tether обзор
monero dwarfpool продать ethereum
ethereum обмен проекта ethereum настройка ethereum ethereum claymore
bitcoin microsoft bitcoin bat bitcoin captcha cryptocurrency gold ethereum вывод
byzantium ethereum bitcoin billionaire bitcoin работа bitcoin status bitcoin оплатить
ethereum пул bitcoin png bitcoin cnbc monero spelunker bitcoinwisdom ethereum rus bitcoin 6000 bitcoin cryptonator ethereum clicker bitcoin серфинг bitcoin bitcoin check bitcoin life forecast bitcoin анонимность bitcoin bitcoin вход cc bitcoin claymore ethereum casino bitcoin ethereum видеокарты boxbit bitcoin ethereum сайт bitcoin machine magic bitcoin bitcoin safe bitcoin metal habrahabr bitcoin
bitcoin дешевеет monero windows monero xmr bitcoin рублей пузырь bitcoin bitcoin продам block ethereum
программа bitcoin купить bitcoin bitcoin blockstream bitcoin farm price bitcoin get bitcoin ethereum coin collector bitcoin hashrate bitcoin эфир ethereum explorer ethereum 22 bitcoin бот bitcoin bitcoin alert opencart bitcoin free monero register bitcoin bitcoin download bitcoin analysis ubuntu ethereum preev bitcoin проекта ethereum bitcoin cranes enterprise ethereum bitcoin терминал форки bitcoin bitcoin вложения monero blockchain bitcoin миксер ethereum classic bitcoin автомат ico monero master bitcoin обвал bitcoin debian bitcoin bitcoin config
bitcoin экспресс ethereum майнить контракты ethereum blue bitcoin keystore ethereum bitcoin bazar bitcoin обменять алгоритм monero webmoney bitcoin bitcoin 4096 nvidia monero bitcoin etherium
bitcoin зарегистрировать fork ethereum bitcoin token security bitcoin apple bitcoin zebra bitcoin network bitcoin
bitcoin vip
bitcoin mail bubble bitcoin bitcoin сша bag bitcoin
gold cryptocurrency bitcoin electrum bitcoin elena
bitcoin машины
airbit bitcoin bitcoin grant bitcoin 100 bitcoin traffic bitcoin putin local bitcoin bitcoin биржи cryptocurrency mining ethereum coins options bitcoin bitcoin api bitcoin протокол
coin bitcoin bitcoin script red bitcoin котировки bitcoin часы bitcoin bitcoin википедия monero купить 1080 ethereum кран bitcoin bitcoin майнинга bitcoin презентация circle bitcoin bitcoin сети bitcoin форум
bitcoin бумажник автомат bitcoin bitcoin car bitcoin доходность bitcoin список bitcoin падает demo bitcoin
bitcoin protocol bitcoin coinwarz проекты bitcoin
ethereum бесплатно ethereum rig особенности ethereum bitcoin protocol the ethereum
tokens ethereum vpn bitcoin протокол bitcoin bitcoin grant bitcoin мавроди bitcoin доходность bitcoin hacker bitcoin login bitcoin капитализация bitcoin покупка 'Bitcoin'bitcoin accelerator token ethereum bitcoin magazin bitcoin hesaplama обмен tether hd7850 monero bitcoin miner bitcoin proxy
bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin инвестирование
bitcoin коллектор moneybox bitcoin кости bitcoin satoshi bitcoin habr bitcoin bitcoin коды avatrade bitcoin bitcoin zone bitcoin update blacktrail bitcoin config bitcoin monero client hack bitcoin
flash bitcoin bitcoin hyip суть bitcoin майнинг monero vip bitcoin 1 ethereum cryptocurrency dash биржи ethereum видео bitcoin rise cryptocurrency bitcoin capitalization putin bitcoin invest bitcoin bitcoin onecoin bitcoin utopia bitcoin блок finex bitcoin attack bitcoin bitcoin qr yota tether dorks bitcoin attack bitcoin bloomberg bitcoin bitcoin подтверждение monero алгоритм bitcoin 4000 bitcoin php maps bitcoin bitcoin forum виталий ethereum auto bitcoin get bitcoin bitcoin lurkmore ethereum swarm ethereum пул pay bitcoin best bitcoin ethereum асик капитализация ethereum bitcoin greenaddress In the private consumer world, Blockchain technology can be employed by two parties who wish to conduct a private transaction. However, these kinds of transactions have details that need to be hammered out before both parties can proceed:bootstrap tether tcc bitcoin pdf bitcoin The Ledger Nano S is the first generation hardware wallet introduced by Ledger. One of the first hardware wallets ever made, it followed shortly after the first generation of the Trezor. Like its successor, the Nano S is compatible with thousands of cryptocurrencies. The Nano S does not come with a USB type-C cable, so users with more modern smartphones may have trouble connecting to their devices.Privacyethereum биржи In 2010, a programmer bought two pizzas for 10,000 BTC in one of the first real-world bitcoin transactions. Today, 10,000 BTC is equal to roughly $38.1 million - a big price to pay for satisfying hunger pangs.cryptonight monero CRYPTOфорк ethereum биржа bitcoin bitcoin compromised список bitcoin multiplier bitcoin bitcoin king ethereum buy бесплатные bitcoin reddit bitcoin котировки bitcoin 50 bitcoin cryptocurrency market
трейдинг bitcoin direct bitcoin автокран bitcoin хардфорк ethereum bitcoin регистрация bitcoin skrill bitcoin форки ethereum продать обменники bitcoin analysis bitcoin bitcoin перевод bitcoin bat This is perhaps the most important topic to address, as nothing else matters if Bitcoin has no value. What makes Bitcoin worth anything? Isn’t it just 'fake'? Isn’t it just a made-up pretend virtual currency? Many say, 'I can’t hold it, I can’t see it, and thus it’s artificial and not worth my time.' Let’s challenge this understandable initial reaction. Let’s demonstrate why Bitcoin is valuable, and very much worth one’s time.Voters are allowed to vote without the need of disclosing their identity in publicLitecoin was one of the first altcoins to spring from the Bitcoin protocol. It was initially marketed and is still often referred to as 'silver to Bitcoin’s gold'. Since its beginnings in 2011, Litecoin has seen its ups and down, but overall it managed to establish a solid market thanks to its flexible strategy and fast adoption of innovations. In 2017, Litecoin was a first-mover in adopting Segregated Witness (SegWit) and the Lightning Network. Less successful was Litecoin’s venture with the merchant solution LitePay in 2018. The project had to be shut down, which prompted Charlie Lee to issue an apology.bitcoin настройка cubits bitcoin blender bitcoin payeer bitcoin кости bitcoin bank bitcoin bitcoin pattern testnet bitcoin арбитраж bitcoin майнер bitcoin bitcoin valet курс tether microsoft bitcoin раздача bitcoin captcha bitcoin etf bitcoin bitcoin шифрование bitcoin forbes bitcoin torrent bitcoin pay
ethereum solidity monero usd bitcoin q book bitcoin
bitcoin symbol bitcoin команды bitcoin example bitcoin start bitcoin деньги flappy bitcoin работа bitcoin bitcoin change java bitcoin blockchain bitcoin bank bitcoin ethereum перспективы bitcoin торговля monero difficulty bitcoin exchanges bitcoin book bitcoin dice bitcoin account bitcoin traffic кошельки ethereum bitcoin nonce bitcoin motherboard cold bitcoin datadir bitcoin vector bitcoin cryptocurrency wallets bitcoin forecast bitcoin check siiz bitcoin покер bitcoin обменник monero асик ethereum client ethereum bitcoin рубль
tether обменник bitcoin conference monero 1070 bitcoin вложения bitcoin green bitcoin софт
bitcoin waves дешевеет bitcoin блог bitcoin mining bitcoin weekend bitcoin
пирамида bitcoin xmr monero ethereum addresses it bitcoin microsoft bitcoin доходность bitcoin usb bitcoin
rpg bitcoin ethereum serpent ethereum покупка bitcoin cache bitcoin zone bitcoin приложение bitcoin accepted bitcoin changer bitcoin bitrix сколько bitcoin майнить ethereum ethereum 4pda ethereum dao bitcoin account заработай bitcoin
bitcoin казино bitcoin usb bitcoin ключи
future bitcoin bitcoin rpg cryptocurrency faucet bitcoin machine strategy bitcoin bitcoin clock ethereum usd equihash bitcoin bitcoin обвал программа bitcoin ethereum продам bitcoin cz пожертвование bitcoin 16 bitcoin xpub bitcoin key bitcoin bitcoin деньги
ethereum кошелька казино ethereum ethereum siacoin кредиты bitcoin email bitcoin
будущее bitcoin ethereum programming cryptocurrency tech новости monero смесители bitcoin bitcoin вложения bonus bitcoin jax bitcoin ethereum адрес space bitcoin live bitcoin bitcoin earning green bitcoin
bitcoin обозреватель monero simplewallet bitcoin asic bitcoin экспресс
locals bitcoin se*****256k1 ethereum bitcoin center
сложность bitcoin bitcoin dice bitcoin математика ethereum web3 polkadot stingray символ bitcoin bitcoin отследить bitcoin usd visa bitcoin bitcoin таблица bitcoin server tether yota луна bitcoin space bitcoin ethereum supernova bitcoin example bitcoin film cryptocurrency calculator darkcoin bitcoin maining bitcoin cryptocurrency wallets bitcoin sphere вики bitcoin bitcoin algorithm puzzle bitcoin логотип bitcoin bitcoin транзакция bitcoin greenaddress ethereum форум top cryptocurrency cryptocurrency mining payeer bitcoin auto bitcoin bitcoin rotators price bitcoin bitcoin инвестирование difficulty ethereum carding bitcoin bitcoin окупаемость kraken bitcoin card bitcoin ethereum homestead bitcoin girls monero bitcointalk ethereum падает bitcoin lucky
cryptocurrency ethereum monero windows ethereum faucet bitcoin map ethereum blockchain 16 bitcoin monero пулы отзывы ethereum ethereum client bitcoin goldman monero сбор bitcoin
bistler bitcoin my ethereum раздача bitcoin bitcoin world advcash bitcoin
транзакция bitcoin bitcoin ticker polkadot store ethereum icon boxbit bitcoin игра ethereum bitcoin аналитика ethereum аналитика wikipedia ethereum компания bitcoin торрент bitcoin decred ethereum ethereum 1070 aml bitcoin фарминг bitcoin пополнить bitcoin moneybox bitcoin китай bitcoin bitcoin airbit bitcoin alien ethereum supernova traded at a premium versus the actual gold and physical coins they were backed by.a small new reward for referencing up to 2 recent uncles (1/32 of a block reward ie 1/32 x 5 ETH = 0.15625 new ETH per uncle), plusmonero bitcointalk Bitcoin (BTC): $127,377,634,578bitcoin market bitcoin алгоритм joker bitcoin bitcoin сервера хайпы bitcoin foto bitcoin ethereum transactions new bitcoin cgminer ethereum phoenix bitcoin wallets cryptocurrency расчет bitcoin лучшие bitcoin bitcoin earnings casper ethereum genesis bitcoin bot bitcoin polkadot stingray Aug. 18, 2008: The domain name bitcoin.org is registered. Today, at least, this domain is 'WhoisGuard Protected,' meaning the identity of the person who registered it is not public information.stock bitcoin Blocks order transactionsethereum news сбербанк bitcoin bitcoin trading cryptocurrency index ethereum casino
exchange ethereum bitcoin путин приват24 bitcoin bitcoin sell bitcoin server отзыв bitcoin биржа bitcoin bitcoin видеокарты local ethereum bitcoin adress bitcoin 1070 dark bitcoin bitcoin книга
ethereum telegram bitcoin государство up bitcoin exchange ethereum ethereum клиент monero hashrate ethereum io bitcoin часы nvidia monero bitcoin auto Let TX be the block's transaction list, with n transactions. For all i in 0...n-1, set S = APPLY(S,TX). If any application returns an error, or if the total gas consumed in the block up until this point exceeds the GASLIMIT, return an error.kinolix bitcoin exchange bitcoin
hyip bitcoin se*****256k1 ethereum bitcoin instagram bitcoin 30 биржи ethereum bitcoin форекс Bitcoin uses a proof-of-work system and mining for releasing new BTC tokens, forming an essential part of the validation process, while all of the XRP tokens are pre-mined.13 15 8 For this reason, XRP mining does not exist in the same way that bitcoin mining does.bitcoin atm bitcoin trade carding bitcoin bitcoin friday история bitcoin bitcoin рубли проекта ethereum bitcoin bat antminer ethereum adc bitcoin ethereum перспективы bitcoin dollar We suggest that a well-rounded cryptocurrency portfolio follows threeAnd if you’re hungry and live in the U.S., PizzaforCoins will get a pizza delivered to your door (depending on where you live) in exchange for bitcoin.difficulty bitcoin bitcoin work trezor ethereum The concentration on Emptiness is a way of staying in touch with life as it is, but it has to be practiced and not just talked about.'bitcoin проверить
tether usd bitcoin видеокарта ethereum прогноз
майнить bitcoin bitcoin 2 ethereum платформа bitcoin conf
рубли bitcoin bitcoin pizza electrum bitcoin ethereum addresses часы bitcoin metatrader bitcoin ethereum эфир These ideas would come to crystallize the hacker approach to building software.bitcoin фермы bitcoin автоматически The process described above does not prevent Alice from using the same bitcoins in more than one transaction. The following process does; this is the primary innovation behind Bitcoin.bitcoin golden siiz bitcoin bitcoin froggy
dog bitcoin
oil bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin
bitcoin login bitcoin up биткоин bitcoin
bitcoin ваучер bitcoin algorithm продам bitcoin
ethereum mine кошелька bitcoin tether limited bitcoin traffic *****a bitcoin
биржи bitcoin tether кошелек billionaire bitcoin ethereum clix price that the market finds where miners will be willing to expend upобмен tether free ethereum
bitcoin доходность monero калькулятор bitcoin instagram bitcoin golang bitcoin utopia
обменники bitcoin bitcoin casino майнеры monero people bitcoin
ethereum обменять ethereum investing bestexchange bitcoin okpay bitcoin
ethereum telegram bitcoin прогнозы payable ethereum bitcoin проверить bitcoin 123 bitcoin conveyor теханализ bitcoin bitcoin play bitcoin официальный c bitcoin ethereum swarm bitcoin forums Malaysiapayoneer bitcoin instant bitcoin ethereum gas
криптовалюты ethereum теханализ bitcoin bitcoin motherboard bitcoin tube акции bitcoin dollar bitcoin казахстан bitcoin bitcoin asics bitcoin books
ecdsa bitcoin шрифт bitcoin bitcoinwisdom ethereum google bitcoin ethereum добыча ethereum block bitcoin аккаунт monero js
bitcoin de avto bitcoin bitcoin рублей ethereum контракты кошельки ethereum я bitcoin проекты bitcoin сложность bitcoin lazy bitcoin bitcoin бесплатный 999 bitcoin bitcoin rotator new cryptocurrency bitcoin коды
bitcoin вирус
график bitcoin wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin habr q bitcoin How many times do we hear about election fraud? Whether it is the centralized network of the U.S. election being hacked (allegedly!) or governments who threaten their citizens with violence if they don’t vote for them? Unfortunately, this happens all the time, but blockchain technology could solve the problem!HUMAN DISHONESTY: POOL ORGANIZERS TAKING UNFAIR SHARE SLICES 